Our Agency

At Goodlad & Swank, we are a team that values integrity in our dealings with clients, insurance carriers, and the professionals with whom we interact. We're a local and family-owned premium agency founded in 2009, serving clients throughout Fort Myers, Naples, Cape Coral, Lehigh Acres and the rest of the beautiful State of Florida.

To better provide for each client we actively seek mastery of the products we offer. We foster relationships with leaders, charities and schools in the communities we serve. We aren’t just Florida Insurance Agents – We are human just like you and insurance clients just like you. We understand. This makes it our utmost goal to provide you the highest level of client service found in the Florida insurance marketplace.

Butch Swank
Butch Swank

Agent Owner

Mary Beck
Mary Beck

Licensed Sales Associate

Stephanie Ostrowski
Stephanie Ostrowski

Office Manager

Larisa Ortiz
Larisa Ortiz

Licensed Sales Associate


Home, Flood & Auto Insurance Throughout Lehigh Acres, Fort Myers & Naples FL

Elevated service sets us apart for Florida Insurance Coverage options.


Goodlad & Swank wants you to know insurance does not have to be complicated. We have partnered with top rated insurance companies writing coverage in Florida for homeowners, auto, flood, business and life insurance. We are committed to providing transparency when quoting your insurance coverage needs and can explain the differences in companies and coverage, so you can make an educated decision. Providing insurance options to Lehigh Acres, Fort Myers, Naples, and the rest of the beautiful State of Florida, you will get the coverage you need at a price that fits your budget.

Request A Quote


Twyla Alvarez has consistently managed all of our insurance needs for the past 15 years. She is highly professional, proactive and efficient, and always provides us with best value for our policies. Twyla is knowledgeable and experienced in her field. Better yet, she combines this knowledge with a special personal and caring touch with her clients. We are very grateful for the positive and trusting relationship we have enjoyed with Twyla over the years. We highly recommend her to anyone seeking advice, support or assistance with their insurance needs.

- Peter and Linda W. - Naples, Florida

I really appreciated the understanding of their agent Wencys’ ability to listen to my insurance requests and her recommendations based on my needs. I appreciated the fact that I felt heard & her understanding, helpfulness & attention to what I was needing. And although I wouldn’t normally use this term with insurance people, I would admit that it really was a delightful experience & have told several friends of how easy it is to work with her. I would recommend everyone to call Goodlad & Swank agency and speak with Wencys.

- Judy B. - Venice, Florida

Had one of the best experience ever at this insurance company. You feel like family and everyone here is friendly. Our insurance agent Mary made the transaction smooth and easy. She was awesome! I can now rest easy knowing we're in good hands.

- Moises Montalvo

Featured Products

Flood Insurance
Flood Insurance

Coverages through the National Flood Insurance Program and private flood insurance carriers.

Home Insurance
Home Insurance

Look after your biggest investment and everything in it with a proper policy.

Auto Insurance
Auto Insurance

Choosing the right auto insurance is the key to keeping you and your car safe.

Life Insurance
Life Insurance

Provide your family with the security they deserve in the event of your passing.

Coverage for Your Business
Coverage for Your Business

We’re committed to keeping your business protected so you can focus on your day-to-day.

Boat Insurance
Boat Insurance

Ensure the safety of your boat or personal watercraft both on and off the water.

Tower Hill Insurance Logo
Safeco logo
Progressive Insurance logo
Travelers Insurance logo
Mercury Insurance Group logo
Bankers Insurance Group Logo
Foremost Insurance logo
GAINSCO Auto Insurance logo
Kemper Logo
MAPFRE Insurance logo
National General Insurance Logo
Titan Insurance logo
Victoria Insurance logo
Windhaven Insurance Logo
American Integrity Insurance logo
Anchor Insurance
American Bankers Insurance Association Logo
Avatar Insurance
Edison Insurance Company Logo
Elements Property Insurance Company logo
Florida Peninsula Insurance logo
Heritage Insurance Logo
National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) Logo
Olympus Insurance Logo
SafePoint Insurance Logo
Safeway Insurance Logo
Southern Fidelity Logo
Tower Hill Insurance Logo
United Property and Casualty Logo
Universal Property & Casualty Insurance
All Risks Ltd. Logo
Appalachian Underwriters Inc Logo
Bankers Insurance Group Logo
CNA Surety Logo
Cypress Insurance logo
First Comp Insurance logo
Markel Insurance logo
RLI Insurance
Zurich Insurance logo
Federal National Insurance Logo
Atlantic Specialty Lines